SkillPedia Skills Encyclopedia
中文 EN

Skills 2026-05-06 13:59 UTC

autodecision

Committed by harshilmathur. Update Category: Bug Fixes & Stability Improvements. Commit details: fix: CLARIFY follow-ups — Sources table format, schema description, parse validation (#14). This update resolves known runtime errors and enhances system reliability.

harshilmathur 967678a harshilmathur/autodecision

CommitRaw commit message

fix: CLARIFY follow-ups — Sources table format, schema description, parse validation (#14)

Three small fixes flagged during PR #11 review and folded into a single
post-merge commit.

1. output-format.md Sources table example + "Required columns" footer were
   describing the ELICIT-only format ("user-inputs.md, provided Apr 2026"),
   while decide.md Step 4b instructs the brief writer to use
   "Source: ELICIT Q1 / CLARIFY Q1". The brief writer had conflicting
   instructions across the two files. Updated the example with both an
   ELICIT-sourced row and a CLARIFY-sourced row, and rewrote the footer
   so the convention is documented in one place.

2. brief-schema.json content_check description for unsourced_dollar_figure
   still said "[U#] = user-inputs.md claim" — describing the tag as
   ELICIT-only. The validator regex itself already accepts [U#] regardless
   of origin, so no behavior change, but the description string appears
   in HARD_FAIL error messages, so a contributor debugging a CLARIFY-cited
   number would have seen misleading guidance. Updated to mention both
   user-inputs.md and iteration-1/clarify-answers.json with a note that
   the Sources column disambiguates origin.

3. clarify.md Step 1.5 fallback (orchestrator writes the questions file
   when the subagent returned JSON inline instead of calling the Write
   tool) was writing the subagent's payload verbatim with no parse step.
   Malformed inline JSON (trailing comma, bad escape, partial output)
   would have produced a broken clarify-questions.json that crashes
   Step 2's read. Tightened to parse first, fall through to
   clarifier_failed on parse error so Step 2 always reads a parseable
   file or sees a typed skip marker.

The fourth item flagged in review (decide.md Step 4b "n = ELICIT count"
not deterministically defined) is not addressed here — it's a theoretical
reproducibility concern about the LLM-driven brief writer's interpretation
of user-inputs.md, the [U#] tag numbers are run-local so cross-brief
inconsistency affects nothing observable. Worth revisiting only if a real
miscount surfaces.

Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>