SkillPedia Skills Encyclopedia
中文 EN

Skills 2026-10-08 01:54 UTC

nsfc-benzi-audit

Committed by jiankang1991. Update Category: New Features & Capability Expansion. Commit details: Add own-route difficulty signal and single-section grading cap; record RED/GREEN runs. This update introduces new capabilities and expands supported use cases.

jiankang1991 9a6010b jiankang1991/nsfc-benzi-audit

CommitRaw commit message

Add own-route difficulty signal and single-section grading cap; record RED/GREEN runs

Source: 公旭中《从技术问题到科学问题》(科学出版社 2026.2), a single-author guide
whose cases are almost all chemical/materials proposals.

Adopted in references/benzi-logic.md:
- Own-route difficulty: check that the rationale says where its own new idea
  is hard and how the plan answers it (建议改 signal, never 必改 alone).
- Excerpt boundary: when only the 关键科学问题 section is supplied, a missing
  unknown is capped at 建议改 with a 待核实 note; full drafts grade as before.

Not adopted after RED runs (current rules already caught them twice each):
method-vs-root-cause link, scientific-question drift vs application code,
decoding of hedged 函评 phrases. Quota-style advice from the book conflicts
with existing signal grading and is not borrowed. A chemistry/materials
domain reference is deferred until a real B/E draft is available.

Runs and scoring: evals/runs/2026-10-07-borrow/README.md

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>