SkillPedia Skills Encyclopedia
中文 EN

Rebuttal-SkillTobiasLee/Rebuttal-Skill

Turns a pile of reviewer comments into an actionable response plan, helping authors decide what needs new experiments,…

No ratings yet Rate this skill
Stars478
Forks21
Watchers478
Open Issues1

InstallOne-line install

Installable · 32 skills

This repository follows the Agent Skills spec, so one command installs it into your AI client — works across Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, Copilot, Windsurf, and 18+ other clients.

npx skills@latest add TobiasLee/Rebuttal-Skill

32 more are not listed — run npx skills@latest add TobiasLee/Rebuttal-Skill --list to see them all.

Add -g install globally (available in every project) · add --agent claude-code to target a client · add --yes to skip the prompts. Restart your AI client afterward and it will pick it up.

OverviewOverview

Key Features

Turns a pile of reviewer comments into an actionable response plan, helping authors decide what needs new experiments, what only needs clarification, and what can be dropped. Key capabilities include: 1. Comment triage and experiment planning: reads the abstract, reviews and scores, classifies each comment into categories such as correctness, empirical support and missing baseline, and flags the results and number of random seeds that need to be supplied; 2. Surface comment vs. underlying concern separation: distinguishes what a reviewer literally wrote from the concern actually driving it, so the response addresses the core objection instead of arguing line by line; 3. Prioritized revision roadmap: outputs a priority-ordered revision roadmap and explicitly lists what not to spend time on, keeping authors away from low-value comments.

Use Cases

writing rebuttals after reviews arrive, planning supplementary experiments from reviewer comments, structuring the response letter, deciding revision priorities under time pressure.

Target Roles

AI / Algorithm Engineer, Data Analyst / Data Engineer, Product Manager (PM).

RatingUser ratings

Nobody has rated this skill yet. Yours would be the first on the site — your vote becomes the initial average.

Rate this skill

Fill it in to be included in the per-role averages below.

One vote per IP,and it cannot be changed after submitting, so choose carefully the first time. No account is collected and no sign-in is required.

RepositoryRepository

Skill ID1882
Data sourceGitHub
RepositoryTobiasLee/Rebuttal-Skill
CategoryAI & Agent Skills / Academic Writing & Peer-Review Response
Primary languageOther
LicenseNot specified
Default branchmain
GitHub repository ID1299966529
Node IDR_kgDOTXvqQQ
Rank#1312 (position within the source ranking)
Site-wide popularity rank#1503 (computed live from Stars, across all 5845 entries)

GrowthStar / Fork growth

One snapshot per day, tracking how Stars and Forks changed

02004006002026-09-252026-10-112026-09-25 · 4752026-10-11 · 478
  • Now478
  • Previous point · 09-25 475
  • vs previous point +3
  • 2 data points 16 days
01020302026-09-252026-10-112026-09-25 · 212026-10-11 · 21
  • Now21
  • Previous point · 09-25 21
  • vs previous point ±0
  • 2 data points 16 days

TimelineTimeline

Repository created2026-07-14 03:31:474 months ago
Data last updated2026-10-26 12:12:1524 days ago
Last commit2026-08-20 07:38:373 months ago

CommitLatest commit

Version [latest] committed by lilei-nlp. Update Category: Feature Addition & Enhancement. Commit details: Address dual-use concerns: add venue AI-policy guidance, replace FULL_REBUTTAL with RESPONSE_DRAFT. This update introduces new capabilities and module extensions.

7315391 vlatest lilei-nlp 2026-08-20